NASCAR’s next safety fix? Less Confederate flags

May 13, 2012 30 Comments »

The image Friday night was just too ironic to ignore.

Brad Daugherty, African American NASCAR commentator and car owner, working for ESPN prior to Nationwide action at Darlington — with a Confederate flag flying from an RV in the infield behind him.

A Confederate flag may fly from the South Carolina State House, but this isn’t a Palmetto State thing. I’ve consistently seen rebel flags at Pocono and Dover, and I’ll be shocked if I don’t see at least some at Watkins Glen and New Hampshire when I make my way to those tracks later in the year.

For Daugherty, a 7-footer with a press credential, there’s a combination of insulation/intimidation factor that likely keeps him from feeling too uncomfortable in what ostensibly would seem to be an unfriendly atmosphere.

But what about the average person of color who wants to enjoy America’s No. 1 spectator sport and feel safe and secure? For all of the talk of NASCAR’s prominence exploding in the past 30 years, you can’t help but wonder how much bigger the sport could have gotten by now if it had created a more inclusive environment at its tracks.

This is a pivotal time for the growth of minority fans. Next Sunday at Iowa Speedway, Darrell Wallace Jr. will make his debut for Joe Gibbs Racing in the Nationwide Series. Wallace, 18, is a product of NASCAR’s Drive for Diversity program, and his wins in the K&N Pro Series make it clear that he could be a major player in NASCAR’s highest ranks for years to come.

For too long, NASCAR wasn’t as proactive as it needed to be in creating opportunities for minority drivers. The governing body figured that the marketplace would take care of the problem itself. NASCAR was wrong.

Noting this history, it’s time for NASCAR to take the lead in educating its fans about symbols that may keep other people from wanting to come to races. NASCAR took a proper first step by keeping PGA golfer Bubba Watson’s “General Lee” from taking to the track at Phoenix.

But there’s a lot more to do. Don’t try to guilt people into leaving their flags at home. Simply explain that creating a more comfortable atmosphere for everyone will bring more fans — subsequently, more revenue for tracks, higher prize money for drivers, additional sponsorship opportunities. Don’t make it about a social agenda. Make it about taking the sport to the next level, and you’ll appeal to all but the most fervent Confederate flag supporters.

There should not be any kind of Confederate flag ban at tracks. This isn’t the University of Mississippi, a state-funded institution, which had every right to jettison rebel flags from its home football games. Instead, NASCAR’s brass needs to be talking to its top owners and drivers, seeking volunteers to appear in at-track video PSAs and signage asking people to reconsider what they fly at the track for the good of the sport.

It’s a tricky balance, trying to nudge people in the right direction without making them feel like you’re telling them what to do. When I moved to New York from North Carolina, I was a smoker. When I would pull out a cigarette on the elevator to go down to Madison Avenue, I couldn’t believe how many people were emboldened enough to say, “Those’ll kill you!” It made me want to go to Duane Reade, buy an extra pack and put five of them in my mouth at the same time.

NASCAR went from backwoods to billionaire by generally displaying a deft marketing touch. I have a feeling they would get this project right, and benefit from the process.

Follow Josh Stewart on Twitter @JoshNASCARWWE

  • http://profiles.google.com/bridgetteshealy bridgette shealy

    You are so stupid. really.

  • Rp Jone

    It’s “FEWER” flags

  • Motorsports4u2

    LOL….you should work for the government as you have the BS thing nailed! Not buying it for a second…..comments like yours hurt the sport instead of helping it. Does Brad have a security team to protect him? No. Because if people of color are interested in auto racing (all types) you would see more of them and they are not afraid to come out. Do you feel scared at a basket ball game?

  • Kharv29

    I’m a minority and have been to a number of NASCAR races from Dover all the way to Daytona (Including Talladega).  Not once have I felt any intimidation from the other fans or the Confederate flag.  NASCAR fans have been nothing but welcoming and open (some of those flying the flag have even asked me and my friends to join and eat with them).  This is a non-issue and seems a bit childish really.

  • Cbc66

    Seriously–you think the stands would suddenly be filled with ‘people of color’ just because racing fans quit flying the Confederat battle flag?  Don’t think so.  I have season tickets at Texas and have seen several Black fans at the track.  They never seemed to be cowered by the flags or the predominatly White crowd.  They were just enjoying the event.  What would put more ‘POC’ in the stands would be a driver who could do for NASCAR what Tiger Woods did for golf.  Maybe this new kid will be that person.  But get off that tired old bandwagon that we have to have ‘inclusive,vanilla’ atmospheres for everyone to feel comfortable. 

  • Ed

    Absolutly right. Let’s get rid of those flags and bring the sport into the 21st century! I notice that the tracks have banned smokinging in the grandstands.
    Now, if we could just get rid of those cars with thier smelly exhausts we would have something!

    What a maroon.

  • Russ

    With all the problems that Nascar has, and I dont have the time or interest to list them, you think this is a problem? Really?

  • jrnation

    motorsports4u2 nailed it, you would be a perfect fit for a government job with your ability to BS people. There are enough race baiters in this country, there is no need for you to throw your hat in the ring too. This is a non issue so stop trying to make it one moron!

  • cocky3

    Do you know how long ago that flag was removed from the dome? I guess not

  • DMan

    obviously you didnt do any research for this article. the confederate flag has nothing to do racism and everything to do with the struggles of the south. i dont live in the south but have friends there and we have had many discussions about the flag. and guess what? not a single one said “I fly the flag because im racist”. it is ignorant reporting and ill-informed comments like yours that perpetuate harmful and damaging myths.

    -DMan

  • Keith

    I’ve been to over 200 cup races and countless Nationwide races and have never seen anyone harrassed about their race. Stop all your B.S. you have no idea what you are talking about and just starting problems.

  • Nas3car

    I became more indignant with each line I read of this bilge, but I see that others have already covered most of the points I would have made. It’s sad that someone as uneducated as you even gets to offer an opinion, but our constitution guarantees you that, whether you live in the north or the south. Do everyone a favor. Go back to school, and this time, learn something… anything. Pay close attention to the part about the Civil War and the reasons for it. The “North” had the steel mills and the foundries. The “South” had King Cotton and the textile mills. The “North” wanted both and the “South” didn’t agree. Read carefully, and you’ll realize that the war was never about color, slavery or any such reason given by some today. The proof can be found in the Carpetbaggers that came south after the war and claimed for themselves what little of the South had not already been destroyed. In short, it was “About the Economy, Stupid.”

    • Reno86

      Actually much of the North’s industry, especially in the New England states, was textile based and were a large buyer of Southern cotton. The South however would have rather sold their cotton to European countries and import European goods under unfair tariffs passed by the previous Southern democrat run congress. The South seceded because the North was against the expansion of slavery, as was the newly elected President Lincoln. Look at most of the documentation from Southern states as to their reason for secession and the newspapers of the time, as opposed to revisionist history, you’ll read about slavery more than economic issues.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/M4RVJ3CUIQPZDOGEH4EN33UZPY BrassRing

    I’ve been an avid NASCAR fan for years and it frustrates me that NASCAR has always been synonomous with “redneck”.   As NASCAR has left the south and grown to a national sport it has made no effort to lose the redneck reputation.  In fact many of the broadcasters go out of their way to further the old NASCAR redneck stereotypes that have held the sport back and kept minorities from becoming more involved.  If Mike Joy makes one more Ricky Bobby comment I’m going to scream.  This is exactly what I’m talking about.  Some hack comedian makes a movie exploiting the outdated stereotypes about the sport and instaed of using it as an opportunity to correct public misconceptions NASCAR eats it up.  That movie alone put NASCAR back 10 years.   I do realize the challenge NASCAR has.  They are trying to grow the sport without losing their core fanbase, which will always be in the south.  With that in mind I am extremely glad NASCAR opted out of the General Lee pace laps thing.  The way to change behavior is to change attitudes.  If NASCAR wants to attract more fans, minorities and otherwise, they first have to lessen or lose their redneck image.  If they manage to do that more people may jump on the NASCAR bandwagon.

  • Doc waldrop

    Are you serious? A “deft marketing touch”…How, by excluding the very fans that brought them to the dance?

  • http://twitter.com/TheCatchFence The Catch Fence ™

    If you don’t like my Confederate flag, then you can kiss my Rebel ass. 

  • Rainy

    I have a residence right outside of Charlotte, NC, and am currently temporarily “living” in Maryland….At HOME I fly my Confederate flag proudly…my non-caucasian neighbors do NOT seem bothered by that fact, as they are familiar with me…HOWEVER, l would NOT fly my flag in Md. due to the narrow minded racists up here who THINK they have an idea of what the flag stands for…When I go to Dover soon in my RV, I WILL fly my Confederate flag as I have for many years…Phoenix and nascar caved to influences by asking Bubba Watson to NOT run pace laps in his General Lee….OMG….are we now going to have reruns of the Dukes Of Hazard pixelate the roof of that car????…The writer of this piece needs to find another subject to glom over since he is wayyyyyyyy off base….Banning any flag at a race will NOT load the stands with non-caucasians, nor make any of them “feel safer” at the venue….(by the way, I have turned down NUMEROUS tickets to basketball games, as THAT venue makes me feel unsafe and I have NO interest in that business)….Brian France has granddaddy spinning in his grave…. 

  • m. brown

     Josh Stewart’s Overview

    Current

    Nassau County Community Editor

    at

    Newsday.com

    Past

    Syosset Editor

    at

    Patch.com

    Syosset Editor

    at
    Patch Media/AOL

    Associate Managing Editor

    at

    Long Island Press

    Associate Managing Editor

    at

    Morey Organization

    Copy editor

    at

    Primedia

    copy editor

    at
    soap opera digest

    sports reporter

    at
    Gaston Gazette

    Sports reporter

    at

    Freedom Communications

    Sports reporter

    at

    Freedom Communications

    see less

    Education

    Gaston College
    Josh is a Long Island trained P.C. LIBERAL. Diversity is a PC joke. I spent (28) years in the US NAVY. The women, blacks, asians, hispanics who were my supervisors during my career where there because we are a MERITOCRACY. The NAVY promotes because of merit not color. When I reached the top of the enlisted ladder, I sat on many selection boards. We NEVER selected someone because of color/gender, only merit.

    Josh, go back to LIBERAL NYC and write about pro wrestling. Your agenda doesn’t sell well here. I spent (28) years in the NAVY to protect Americans’s right to fly whatever flag you wan to fly from your home/RV including the NAZI, Black Power, Palestine, Israeli, etc flags.

    Also IRS regulations consider an self contained RV with sleeping, dining and restroom facilities as a home and as such you can’t tell me what to attach to MY second home and you are NOT coming in it without a search warrant if you are a LEO.

    Yankee by birth, Southerner by the Grace of God.

  • Butch Summey

    What a bunch of Horse manure, you are an idiot!

  • Brattkustomz

    Josh,

    You are more ignorant than the people that you are attacking in your column.   It’s mindless babble from people like you that keep the whole racism fire burning.  NASCAR is a multi-color, all inclusive sport(just look at the cars that are racing).  You need to pull your head out of your…        …19th century mindframe and join all of us NASCAR, and race fans in general, in the 21st century.  I’m betting that you’re a Liberal Democrat that would like to have Affirmative Action forced on NASCAR so that we could get more “color” in the drivers seats.  As far as commenting about Brad Daugherty and him possibly being uncomfortable with a Confederate flag flying near him, I think Brad can take care of himself.  He doesn’t need a moron like you coming to his defense. 

  • Johhnyo

    When you left NC to go to NY, well you sure as hell did the south a favor by moving your dumb ass up North where you belong

  • Ed in Georgia

    First off, is should be “Fewer Confederate Flags”.   Can’t imagine your editor let that on slip by.

    Second.  Stock Car Racing was born and raised in the South.  Those of us who live in the South have a proud heritage.  We’re not “Irish Americans”, :”German Americans” & etc.   We’re Americans who are from, and love, the South.  For years, you racists have been stirring the Kettle of hate by attempting to depict the “Confederate Battle Flag”  (No, it’s not the Flag of the Confederate States of America, but you didn’t actually know that.).  When you see the “Flag” consider it a statement of Heritage and love of the South and not the symbol of hate you so badly want it to be.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_H4Q5IDSLI2UJIMKJW567JUULS4 Terry

    With due respect .. of my eight great-great grandfathers, seven served in the Civil War, six fought for the South, five fought at Gettysburg and three are still there. Not a single one owned a slave. I am not racist but neither am I willing to condemn the flag under which my family fought. The “Confederate flag” that most people fly is the military battle flag. It is due to the honor given ANY American flag. I would, however, accept that the flag of the government of the Confederacy, the true “stars and bars,” is a flag that symbolizes a political system founded on the defense of slavery. I don’t fly that flag, don’t display it in any form nor do I know anyone who does.
    So, with the respect due this piece of … journalism (ahem) … “Kiss my Southern Butt!”

  • GQ03

    Its a safety issue?  When was the last lynching or hate crime that took place at a NASCAR race? What exactly are you implying?  There is a world of difference between being uncomfortable because of ignornance, and being in danger because of a racist lynch mob.  You are over the line.

  • http://bumpdrafter.blogspot.com/ Jdavis88hub

    BrassRing I somewhat disagree.  NASCAR having southern roots does not necessarily make those roots “redneck”, which is a negative term to describe certain white people.  Should we use negative terms to describe people of other races?  Oh yes, that would be racist.  NASCAR has moved away from it southern roots in both marketing and in race placement, which has not necessarily strengthened its marketshare.  Not every person with a confederate flag is racist, nor do most of them pose any threat to Mr. Daugherty or any other person of color.  Perhaps before the writer of this site supposed what Mr. Daugherty felt about the scenery at the track they should have asked him.  Let’s hear HIS sentiments, not assume them.

  • catgirl

    Seriously?? You probably consider yourself an activist. Go hug a tree. Look, the reason NASCAR is in a slump has nothing to do with ‘race’ and their lack of sensitivity. It’s simple – the fans are broke and the tracks are continuing to ‘break’ them. Families simply cannot afford to go to the track anymore. Anyone that has ever been to a race knows how much more exciting it is ‘live’. Fans still follow their favorite drivers, they just don’t want to watch all ‘crap’ that the media pushes on them when they watch it on tv. Also, I feel certain that if you ask the fans what drives their spending, it’s based on price these days. While fans want to support their favorite drivers and teams, they still have to feed their families. Why are they going to spend more at the store to put more money in the pockets of teams, drivers, retailers and manufacturers – not to mention NASCAR, when they already strapped? Stop trying to make ‘race’ an excuse for why NASCAR is in a decline. I’ve followed the sport for 15+ years now and have likely been to more tracks than you. Trust me when I say that I have NEVER seen an incident where race was an issue, no matter the track or whether it was below or above the Mason Dixon Line. Either you like racing or you don’t. There is no ‘gray’ area. If NASCAR wants to fix the sport they should work with ISC and SMI to lower costs for events and trim the fat from the top. Fans are going back to their local tracks – where it’s not only affordable but enjoyable to watch a race. I bet you never see the seats at home tracks empty these days. Bowman Gray certainly isn’t having problems packing the stands. Racing is supposed to be our source on entertainment, not a blister in our pocket. Do us all a favor and find a new job. You’re not very good at the one you have. We have enough problems with the world – we don’t need close-minded pin-heads like you trying to create an issue that doesn’t exist. Although I am a southerner, I have traveled the globe (call me a redneck now) and I proudly display the American flag alongside the Confederate flag, because I’m proud to be both. I’m sure your next article will be supporting the vote to enforce a dress code – like khaki’s and dress shirts. Get a grip! And visit your local library while you’re at it!

  • Banzaibonnie

    Since I’m Irish, by your logic, I should be offended, and intimidated by the british flag,but since I wasn’t constantly reminded of the horrors perpetrated on my ancestors by the English, I actually like most people from the U. K.!! Imagine that!

  • Reno86

    Sweet Jesus! Say one disparaging word about the Confederate flag and the hillbillies are ready to break out the tar and feathers! Josh never said that people who wave the Confederate flag were racists. The flag stands for a South that fought to maintain a way of life that included slavery, and don’t give me that “economics” crap! It was the economics of slavery that led the South to secede. Given that, I would believe that it’s reasonable to think that the Confederate flag might alienate some potential black fans. It’s like wearing a swastika t-shirt because the swastika was a good luck symbol before the Nazi’s used it. How many Jewish friends do you think you’re going to make wearing that? It’s ok to have Southern pride but if it all hinges on your need to wave a symbol of the losing side from a war fought 147 years ago, your pride isn’t very substantial. Now let the, ever so genuis, name calling begin!

  • Eddie

    They done ruined football and basket ball they cant ruin nascar too the naacp can kiss my ass

  • Al Hoove

    Here’s how stupid this attempt to diminish the rebel flag is: the Quantril flag can replace it. Google it.